Romance in E minor, S.169
Romance S.169, the theme of which is based on the song "O pourquoi donc" ("Why, oh Why"), is a piece of music written in 1848 by the Hungarian composer Franz Liszt during a visit to Moscow. It bears some resemblance to Chopin's Nocturne in E minor, as both pieces commence with broken E-minor chords.
The piece would eventually be a predecessor for the Romance oubliée S.527 ("Forgotten Romance"), which was published more than 30 years after Romance S.169 was written. Friedrich Schnapp described the Romance S.169 as a "piece of music written in his youthful years", whereas the Romance oubliée can be seen as a slightly impressionistic old man's reminiscence.
Most recent recordings
- Romance in E Minor "O pourquoi donc", S. 169 — Franz Liszt, Luis Kolodin (2025) Spotify
- Romance in E Minor, S.169/LW.A148 — Franz Liszt, Gabriele Bagnati (2025) Spotify
- Romance in E Minor (O pourquoi donc), S. 169 — Franz Liszt, German Kitkin (2024) Spotify
New releases via Spotify — surfaced automatically, not editorial picks.

